Welcome to the hills — every strong food opinion I have, in one place.
I have a lot of strong food opinions and I have never once been talked out of a single one. That is what this whole series is. Every week or so I plant a flag on something — a condiment, a candy, a bag of chips, the correct way to eat a hot dog — and then I go looking for backup, which is genuinely my favorite part. Sometimes I come back with a Nobel Prize winner. Sometimes I come back with a federal agency. Once I came back with a nun from the twelfth century.
None of it is serious and all of it is true. These are the things I actually believe about food, said out loud, with my whole chest, in the full knowledge that some of you are going to disagree with me in the comments. Please do. That is the point. Half the fun of having a hill is finding out who else is standing on it and who is down at the bottom hollering up.
This page contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. If you purchase through my links, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Thank you for supporting StephanieCooksForACrowd.com!
🔔 Just here to see what is new?
The newest hills are right below. If you would rather have the whole run in date order, every hill is archived here, newest first.
- The Hill I Will Die On: Mashed Potatoes and Gravy Beat Mac and Cheese
- The Hill I Will Die On: Team Dunkin’ Donuts Over Starbucks, All Day, Every Day
- The Hill I Will Die On: Coffee Really Does Taste Better in the Right Mug
- The Hill I Will Die On: Candy Corn Is the Most Offensive Halloween Candy
Start Here — The Strong Food Opinions That Started the Most Trouble
If you are new here, start with these four. They are the ones that got the most arguing, the most comments, and in one case the most trouble inside my own house.
Every Strong Food Opinion, Sorted by the Kind of Argument
Strong food opinions do not all work the same way. Some of them are about a condiment. Some are a defense of something cheap that people look down on. Some are me telling you a food is simply wrong. Here they are grouped by the kind of fight they are, because that is how you actually browse an argument — you go looking for the one you disagree with.
The Condiment Wars
- Hot Dogs Only Want Ketchup and Mustard — a divided house and a trade association that came for me personally.
- Chick-fil-A Sauce Is the Best Waffle Fry Sauce — my sauce against Alex’s Polynesian, and the official rankings back me up.
- Eggs and Ketchup — not on my eggs, not on my hashbrowns, not at my breakfast table.
- Chili Is Meat and Beans, Not Noodles — a young preacher’s wife, a chili cook-off in Louisville, and a grudge I have carried ever since.
- Team Oregano — I Can Pass on Basil Every Time — the herb aisle has a correct answer and it is not the trendy one.
Cheap Food I Will Not Apologize For
- Totino’s Frozen Pizza Is Worth Every Bite — a cheap little party pizza for lunch, and not one ounce of embarrassment.
- A Bologna Sandwich Is the Best Beach Lunch — white bread, American cheese, a little mayo, sandy feet, and a paper towel for a plate.
- My Top 5 Chips, Ranked and Final — five chips, one company, and two of them are not chips.
- Milk Duds Are the Perfect Movie Theater Candy — dropped one at a time into a tub of buttery popcorn, which is the whole technique.
- Klondike Bars Beat the Drumstick — a blind panel of judges disagreed with me and I stood my ground anyway.
Foods That Are Simply Wrong
- Cottage Cheese — I Refuse — the trendiest food on the internet and I am sitting this one out.
- Peeps Are a Crime Against Food — they show up every spring completely uninvited.
- Matcha Anything — No Thank Ya — it tastes like chalky grass and the empress has no clothes.
- Decaf Coffee Is an Abomination — it should cease to exist, and I meant it before I finished the first cup.
- Tomatoes Are the Best Flavor and the Worst Bite — the best flavor in my kitchen, and the tomato hid it inside the slimy part.
- Candy Corn Is the Most Offensive Halloween Candy — it was first sold as Chicken Feed, and there is not one kernel of corn in it.
Made for Each Other
- Foods Made for Each Other Belong Together — five food marriages, and what the Lord has put together let no man pull apart on a plate.
- Watermelon and Corn Are the Taste of Summer — one fruit, one vegetable, and the whole season in two bites.
- Breakfast for Dinner Beats Breakfast at Breakfast Time — same eggs, same bacon, different hour, entirely different meal.
- A Sandwich Always Tastes Better When Somebody Else Makes It — I went looking for a scientist and came back with a Nobel Prize winner.
The Best Flavor, Full Stop
- Chocolate Ice Cream Is the Star of the Show — vanilla is the backup singer and always has been.
- Hazelnut Is the Best Flavor — when my coffee tastes extra good, that is why. Every single time.
- Pumpkin Spice Is the Best Coffee Flavor — a medieval nun, a federal agency, and the entire village of Morton, Illinois are behind me on this.
- Black Licorice Jelly Beans Are the Best Jelly Bean — I know exactly what this costs me and I am saying it anyway.
- Dole Whip Is Magic Kingdom’s Best Snack — defended from my own kitchen while the rest of my crew was at the park without me.
Foods I Would Defend in Court
- Bread Is Life and Life Without Bread Is No Life — I have watched people push a roll to the side of the plate like it was a napkin.
- Pork Is a Wonderful, Magical Animal — ham, bacon, chops, sausage, pulled pork and ribs, all off the same astonishing animal.
- Tacos Are the Most Brilliant Food Ever Invented — they feed a crowd, they use up leftovers, and the name has an explosive origin story.
- The Carrot Is the Most Superior Vegetable — the first flag I ever planted, and I am not accepting counteroffers.
- Movie Theater Popcorn Over Candy, Every Time — one snack, the whole movie, and candy already lost this fight once during sugar rationing.
- Honeycomb Is the One Cereal I Could Eat Every Day Forever — sweet but not too sweet, still crunchy in the milk, and soggy cereal once won a physics prize.
- Perfectly Cooked Steak Beats Crème Brûlée Every Time — one crust is sugar, the other is dinner, and the fancy one got its fancy from a name change.
- Coffee Really Does Taste Better in the Right Mug — four nickels of weight fooled a room full of coffee experts, so I am keeping my big mugs.
- Team Dunkin’ Donuts Over Starbucks, All Day, Every Day — I like both, but more coffee drinkers like Dunkin’, and Starbucks itself admitted 54 million of us wanted a lighter roast.
- Mashed Potatoes and Gravy Beat Mac and Cheese — my own kids are Team Mac, but five years of surveys and a turkey stuffed with mashed potatoes in 1796 are on my side.
💬 Now go tell me I am wrong. Every one of these has a comment section and I read all of them. Find the hill you disagree with hardest, scroll to the bottom, and let me have it — the best arguments I have gotten have come from people who think I have completely lost my mind.
Strong Food Opinions — Your Questions
How do you decide what counts as a hill?
It has to be something I actually believe and something a reasonable person could argue with. If everybody already agrees, it is not a hill, it is just a fact. And it has to be small — I am not planting a flag on anything that matters. That is sort of the whole charm of it.
Can I suggest one?
Please do, and people already have. Leave it in the comments on any of these or send it to me on TikTok or Instagram. Some of my favorite ones started as somebody telling me I was wrong about something else entirely.
Do you really mean all of these, or is it a bit?
I mean every one of them. The delivery is for fun; the opinions are real. I really will not eat cottage cheese, I really do put ketchup on a hot dog, and I really did rank five bags of chips in order and refuse to move any of them after finding out they all came from the same company.
Where do the strong food opinions start before they end up here?
They start as short text-on-screen videos on TikTok and Instagram — fifteen seconds, one opinion, no explanation. The written version is where I actually make the case and bring the receipts, which is usually where it gets interesting.
📬 Come to the table on Saturday
Every Saturday morning I send a printable meal plan and full grocery list — the whole week, formatted for the fridge and the grocery run — plus new recipes, whatever’s happening at the Longstreth house, and every so often a brand new hill. Drop your email below and I’ll save you a seat.
Strong Food Opinions — About Stephanie Longstreth
Stephanie Longstreth is the home cook, mom, and storyteller behind StephanieCooksForACrowd.com. She cooks for a family of seven in Florida — five kids, two cats, and one husband who appreciates a good meal. Four of her children came home through adoption, and family stories are woven into everything she makes and shares. Find her crowd-friendly recipes, weekly meal plans, and real family life on TikTok, Instagram, YouTube, and Pinterest @stephaniecooksforacrowd.




