The hill I will die on chips — Stephanie's graphic ranking the top 5 chips: Doritos nacho cheese, Ruffles sour cream and cheddar, Miss Vickie's smokehouse BBQ, Lay's sour cream and onion, and Cheetos cheese puffs
| |

The Hill I Will Die On: My Top 5 Chips, and I Have Put a Lot of Thought Into This

The hill I will die on chips — Stephanie's graphic ranking the top 5 chips: Doritos nacho cheese, Ruffles sour cream and cheddar, Miss Vickie's smokehouse BBQ, Lay's sour cream and onion, and Cheetos cheese puffs

The hill I will die on chips is not one I wandered onto by accident, and I want that on the record before anybody starts typing: I have put a lot of thought into this. Here is the list, in order. One, Doritos Nacho Cheese. Two, Ruffles Sour Cream & Cheddar. Three, Miss Vickie’s Smokehouse BBQ. Four, Lay’s Sour Cream & Onion. Five, Cheetos Cheese Puffs. That is the top five chips out there, that is the correct order, and I am standing on this hill with an open bag in my lap. 🥔

This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. If you purchase through my links, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Thank you for supporting StephanieCooksForACrowd.com!

Now, y’all know by now that I do not plant a flag without going looking for backup first, and the very first thing I found out is that I have been saying one of these names wrong for years. It is not Ms. Vickers. It is Miss Vickie’s — and Miss Vickie is a real woman. Her name is Vickie Kerr, and in 1987 she started making chips on her family’s potato farm in New Lowell, Ontario, for one reason: she wanted something better than what was on the shelf for her own kids to eat. She and her husband Bill fried them in peanut oil and hauled them to the potato festival over in Alliston that fall, and they sold clean out. That is the entire origin story. A mother stood in a farm kitchen, decided the chips available to her were not good enough for her children, and made her own instead. Six years later she sold the company to Frito-Lay, and forty years later they are in my grocery store in Florida. I have never been so happy to be corrected about anything in my life.

And then I found the thing that took the wind straight out of my sails. I picked these five carefully, y’all. Different brands, different textures, different corners of the snack aisle — a broad and worldly list, I thought, assembled by a woman of discernment. Then I pulled up Frito-Lay’s own brand page and there they all sat. Doritos. Ruffles. Miss Vickie’s. Lay’s. Cheetos. Every single one of my five belongs to the same company. I did not build a top five. I built a shopping list for one manufacturer, and I did it with a completely straight face, and then I announced that I had put a lot of thought into it.

Hill I Will Die On Chips — Two of My Top Five Are Not Even Chips

It gets worse before it gets better. Doritos are a tortilla chip, not a potato chip. And Cheetos are not a chip in any sense whatsoever — they are cornmeal and water pushed through a machine, puffed up, and dusted with cheese powder. So out of the five chips I so carefully ranked, three of them are chips. I am aware of what that does to my credibility. I am also not moving one single thing on that list.

The Doritos story is worth the detour. In the early 1960s Frito-Lay ran a restaurant inside Disneyland called Casa de Fritos, over in Frontierland, and the tortillas for the kitchen came in from a local supplier. Somebody had the idea that instead of throwing out the surplus tortillas, they ought to cut them up and fry them and sell them. A Frito-Lay executive named Arch West ate one on a family trip, went home, and pushed to make them by the truckload. The name comes from the Spanish for little golden things, the first ones were not flavored at all, and nacho cheese — my number one, the one I put at the top of my own list before I knew a single one of these facts — did not arrive until 1972 and went on to become the flavor that made the whole brand. So I picked the same one everybody else picked. Fine. It is still first.

Cheetos are older than that, and they trace back to the man who started all of it. Charles Elmer Doolin invented Fritos in 1932 and Cheetos in 1948, and Doolin is the one who opened Casa de Fritos at Disneyland in the first place. Which means the restaurant that accidentally produced my number one chip was founded by the man who deliberately produced my number five. Ruffles had its own inventor too, a man named Bernhardt Stahmer, who went and got himself a patent in the fifties on sliced, corrugated potato products — on the theory that the ridges made the chip sturdier and better for dipping. He was right. That is exactly why the ridge is the whole point, and exactly why a flat chip standing in a bowl of something thick is a broken promise waiting to happen.

Here is the part I have not been able to stop thinking about since. An experimental psychologist at Oxford named Charles Spence sat people down with headphones on and had them eat chips while he quietly turned the crunch sound up and down. Same chip. Same bite. Same everything except what their ears were being told. People rated the chips with the louder, higher-pitched crunch about fifteen percent fresher. He won an Ig Nobel Prize for it in 2008, and it turned out to be a serious finding about how the brain fuses what you hear with what you feel in your mouth. Which explains my whole third slot. Miss Vickie’s are kettle cooked, which makes them thicker and louder, and some of what I have been calling flavor all these years is apparently noise. It also explains why a soft chip is such a specific kind of betrayal. It is not that a stale chip tastes bad. It is that it went quiet on you.

But the real reason chips get this much thought out of me is that they do a job at my house that nothing else does. I feed seven people. A bag of chips is the thing that turns a sandwich into a lunch, fills the last empty corner of a plate, and buys me twenty quiet minutes on a Saturday afternoon. They ride in every lunchbox I pack, and my school lunch ideas kids will eat post is really just a long argument for a well-chosen side. And no cookout for a crowd has ever left my kitchen without at least three bags going out on that table, because the chip bowl is the one dish at a cookout that nobody expects you to have made. Two dollars and a bowl and you have covered a whole end of the table. Say what you want about the snack aisle. It has never once let me down in front of company.

Hill I Will Die On — Chips FAQ

Is the hill I will die on chips a real ranking, or just five chips you happen to like?

It is a real ranking and I will defend the order, but I will be honest with you about what it is a ranking of. It is not the best chips ever made anywhere. It is the five bags that have earned a permanent spot in my house, in the order I would grab them if I could only carry five out of the store. That is a ranking. It is just an extremely personal one.

Doritos are not a potato chip. Does that not disqualify them?

The bag says chips, the aisle says chips, and every single person who has ever handed me one at a party called it a chip. I am not going to be the woman who redraws the borders of the snack aisle on a technicality. If it is thin, it is salty, it is fried, and it comes out of a crinkly bag, it is a chip and it is eligible.

Why the cheese puffs instead of crunchy Cheetos?

Because a puff dissolves and a crunchy one fights back. The puff gives up the cheese immediately, it does not shred the roof of your mouth, and you can eat a handful without feeling like you went twelve rounds. Crunchy Cheetos are perfectly good. Puffs are better, and I say that as somebody who has bought both this month.

Where are Pringles, Fritos, and salt and vinegar?

Fritos I love and Fritos belong in chili, not in a bowl by themselves, so they are competing in a different event. Salt and vinegar is a wonderful chip that makes my whole mouth pucker after about nine of them, and a top five has to be a chip I can keep eating. Pringles I will simply say this about: a chip that comes in a tube and stacks perfectly has been engineered, and I like mine a little less organized than that.

What is the one chip you will not eat?

Any chip that has gone soft, and I mean any of them, including all five of the ones I just ranked. A chip has exactly one job in this world and it is texture. The second that bag has been left open on the counter overnight, whatever is in it is not a chip anymore — it is a snack-shaped disappointment, and it goes in the trash without a funeral.

🛒 The Top Five, In Order

The whole hill in one place, ranked exactly the way I ranked it — click any bag to shop on Amazon. Fair warning: the grocery store is cheaper, these are the party-size bags, and Miss Vickie’s only comes as a multipack. Nobody is making anybody buy chips.

Doritos, Nacho Cheese Flavored Tortilla Chips Party Size, 15 oz
Doritos, Nacho Cheese Flavored Tortilla Chips Party Size, 15 oz
15 oz. bag of Doritos Nacho Cheese Flavored Tortilla Chips; Crunchy chips and boldness make DORITOS snacks awesome and great for your pantry
Ruffles Potato Chips, Cheddar & Sour Cream, 12.5 oz Party Size Bag
Ruffles Potato Chips, Cheddar & Sour Cream, 12.5 oz Party Size Bag
Includes 1 (12.5 oz) party size bag of Ruffles Cheddar & Sour Cream Potato Chips
Miss Vickies Kettle Cooked Smokehouse BBQ Potato Chips, 1.375 oz Bags, Pack of 8
Miss Vickies Kettle Cooked Smokehouse BBQ Potato Chips, 1.375 oz Bags, Pack of 8
Large single-serving size bags, enough to staisfy an adult sized craving.
$17.33
Lay's Potato Chips, Sour Cream & Onion Flavored, 12.5 Oz
Lay's Potato Chips, Sour Cream & Onion Flavored, 12.5 Oz
Includes 1 (12.5oz) Party Size! bag of Lay's Sour Cream & Onion Potato Chips; It all starts with farm-grown potatoes, cooked and seasoned to perfection.
Cheetos Puffs Cheese 13.5oz Party Size! Bag
Cheetos Puffs Cheese 13.5oz Party Size! Bag
Includes 1 (13.5oz) Party Size! Bag of Cheetos Puffs; Bold, cheesy flavor with a light and airy texture

↑ Back to Top

So that is the hill I will die on chips, and I will grant that I climbed it holding one company’s entire product line and calling it a considered opinion. I regret nothing. Now tell me in the comments where I got it wrong — because somebody is about to point out that the Ruffles bag has said Cheddar & Sour Cream this whole time and I have had those two words backwards for years, right alongside Ms. Vickers. Somebody else is going to make a real case for kettle chips, and at least one of you is going to say Funyuns and mean it. I want to hear every bit of it. What is your number one, and what did I leave off?

More Hills Worth Dying On — Strong Food Opinions from Stephanie

🍳 More from My Kitchen

📅 My Weekly Meal Plans — A full week of dinners with a printable shopping list, every Saturday.

📖 My Cookbooks — My recipes, with the planning already done.

🧢 Shop My Merch — Everything from my kitchen to yours — wear it, gift it, cook in it.

🍴 Shop My Kitchen — The tools I cook with, plus every ingredient I keep stocked.

🛒 My Amazon Storefront — Curated lists for every kind of recipe.

📬 Come to the table on Saturday

Every Saturday morning I send a printable meal plan and full grocery list — the whole week, formatted for the fridge and the grocery run — plus new recipes and whatever’s happening at the Longstreth house. Drop your email below and I’ll save you a seat.

The Hill I Will Die On — About Stephanie Longstreth

Stephanie Longstreth is the home cook, mom, and storyteller behind StephanieCooksForACrowd.com. She cooks for a family of seven in Florida — five kids, two cats, and one husband who appreciates a good meal. Four of her children came home through adoption, and family stories are woven into everything she makes and shares. Find her crowd-friendly recipes, weekly meal plans, and real family life on TikTok, Instagram, YouTube, and Pinterest @stephaniecooksforacrowd.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *