Mashed potatoes vs mac and cheese — the hill I will die on: at the Thanksgiving dinner table, mashed potatoes and gravy, not mac n cheese, hands down
| |

The Hill I Will Die On: Mashed Potatoes and Gravy Beat Mac and Cheese

Mashed potatoes vs mac and cheese — the hill I will die on: at the Thanksgiving dinner table, mashed potatoes and gravy, not mac n cheese, hands down

Mashed potatoes vs mac and cheese is the Thanksgiving side dish fight at my house, and I am not even a little bit undecided. When it comes to the Thanksgiving dinner table, the more important side is mashed potatoes and gravy. Hands down. 🥔🥔🥔

This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. If you purchase through my links, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Thank you for supporting StephanieCooksForACrowd.com!

Specifically when discussing the Thanksgiving dinner table: do you rank mashed potatoes and gravy or Mac n cheese in the more important side? For me— it’s mashed potatoes and gravy. Hands Down!! This is a hill I will die on! 😜🥔🥔🥔

Let me explain myself. Mashed potatoes and gravy are not one side dish, they are two that belong together, and together they hold the whole plate up. The gravy goes on the potatoes, and then it goes on the turkey, and then it goes on the stuffing, and before you know it everything on your plate is connected. My gravy starts with the drippings from my roaster oven turkey, which is the whole reason I tell you to save them. Mac and cheese is delicious. I am not here to say a single bad word about it. But it sits in its own corner of the plate and minds its own business. Mashed potatoes and gravy are what make it Thanksgiving dinner.

Here is the case against me, and I am going to state it fairly, because it is a good one. Mac and cheese has a lot of fans, and some of the loudest ones live in my house. Jason is on my side. The kids are not. If mac and cheese shows up on my Thanksgiving table, it is because the kids asked for it, and they will tell you it is the best thing on the table. And they have backup. Mac and cheese is the number one Thanksgiving side for Gen Z, more than half of Americans call it the one dish everybody can agree on, and plenty of people will tell you there are never any leftovers. In the Southeast it is on two out of every three tables. And last year my own state, Florida, picked mac and cheese as its number one Thanksgiving side. My own state voted against me.

Mashed Potatoes vs Mac and Cheese — The Backup I Found

Y’all know I do not plant a flag without going to find some backup, and this time I found five years of it. Every year Campbell’s runs a big survey on Thanksgiving side dishes. This year they asked 5,017 adults who celebrate Thanksgiving, 100 in every single state. Mashed potatoes came in number two in the whole country, right behind stuffing. Mac and cheese came in fourth.

Then I looked at all five years of the survey, and that is where it got good. Since 2022, mashed potatoes have finished second, first, second, second and second. They have never once ranked lower than number two, and in 2023 they beat out stuffing for the top spot. Mac and cheese did not make the top five at all in 2022, and the best it has ever done is third. State by state, mashed potatoes are the number one side, or tied for it, in seven states this year. Mac and cheese is number one in four. Even Campbell’s own report says mashed potatoes are quietly building an empire, and Campbell’s is the company selling the cheese soup for your mac and cheese. You can read the whole Campbell’s report here.

And about Florida: this year Florida switched to stuffing. So the Sunshine State did not come back to my side, but at least it stopped voting for the other one. Florida also serves more side dishes at Thanksgiving than any other state, 9.4 per table, so I am going to guess there is a pan of mashed potatoes on almost every one of them.

Mashed Potatoes Were Inside the Turkey Before Mac and Cheese Ever Showed Up

Here is the twist. Neither one of these was at the first Thanksgiving in 1621. Potatoes had not made it to New England yet, and the Pilgrims did not have the flour to make a real gravy. So nobody wins on that one.

But look at the very first cookbook ever written by an American, Amelia Simmons’s American Cookery, printed in 1796. Her recipe for how to stuff and roast a turkey gives you a few ways to fill the bird, and one of them is to boil and mash three pints of potatoes, wet them with butter, add herbs, pepper and salt, fill the bird and roast it. The stuffing was mashed potatoes! And the same recipe tells you to baste the bird with the gravy. You can read her whole cookbook for free, spelling and all. Mashed potatoes and gravy have been riding along with the turkey since the very first American cookbook.

Mac and cheese came along a few years later. In 1802, a congressman who ate dinner at President Thomas Jefferson’s house wrote down that he was served “a pie called macaroni,” and he did not like it one bit. He thought it was full of onions. Jefferson’s secretary, Meriwether Lewis, had to tell him those were the noodles. Monticello still has his notes. Historians often credit James Hemings, the enslaved chef Jefferson had trained in Paris, with helping bring that kind of cooking to American tables, and mac and cheese has been part of holiday dinners ever since, especially across the South. It has a real history, and I respect it. I just respect mashed potatoes more.

And when I planned my whole holiday dinner for 25 people in The Holiday Table for 25, two pans of mashed potatoes and my brown gravy made the menu. Mac and cheese did not. If you want mine for your table this year, here are my Creamy Baked Mashed Potatoes, and you can make them ahead. For the rest of the spread, my side dishes for a crowd are all in one place.

Hill I Will Die On — Mashed Potatoes vs Mac and Cheese FAQ

Mashed potatoes vs mac and cheese: which one is more popular at Thanksgiving?

Mashed potatoes. In Campbell’s 2026 survey, mashed potatoes ranked second in the country and mac and cheese ranked fourth. In five years of that survey, mashed potatoes have never ranked lower than second, and mac and cheese has never ranked higher than third.

But isn’t mac and cheese the one everybody agrees on?

A lot of people say so, and Gen Z has ranked it number one two years in a row. My kids would agree with them. But agreeing on it is not the same as needing it, and Thanksgiving dinner without mashed potatoes and gravy would feel like something was missing.

Why not just make both?

You can, and if my kids ask, I will. But this is a hill, and a hill means if you only get one, which one do you pick? I pick mashed potatoes and gravy every time.

Didn’t your own state pick mac and cheese?

Last year it did. Florida named mac and cheese its number one Thanksgiving side in the 2025 survey. This year Florida switched to stuffing, so I am choosing to call that progress.

What about stuffing?

Stuffing is the number one side in the country, and I love it too. But in the very first American cookbook, one of the ways to stuff the turkey was with mashed potatoes, so I am counting that as one more point for my side.

So that is where I stand on mashed potatoes vs mac and cheese, and it is the hill I will die on: at the Thanksgiving dinner table, mashed potatoes and gravy are the more important side, hands down. Now tell me, which team are you on? Mashed potatoes and gravy with me and Jason, or mac and cheese with my kids? Put it in the comments, and I will read every single one. And if you are team mac and cheese, you are still welcome at my table. You might just have to ask for it. 😉

More Hills Worth Dying On — Strong Food Opinions from Stephanie

🍳 More from My Kitchen

📅 My Weekly Meal Plans — A full week of dinners with a printable shopping list, every Saturday.

📖 My Cookbooks — My recipes, with the planning already done.

🧢 Shop My Merch — Everything from my kitchen to yours — wear it, gift it, cook in it.

🍴 Shop My Kitchen — The tools I cook with, plus every ingredient I keep stocked.

🛒 My Amazon Storefront — Curated lists for every kind of recipe.

📬 Come to the table on Saturday

Every Saturday morning I send a printable meal plan and full grocery list — the whole week, formatted for the fridge and the grocery run — plus new recipes and whatever’s happening at the Longstreth house. Drop your email below and I’ll save you a seat.

The Hill I Will Die On — About Stephanie Longstreth

Stephanie Longstreth is the home cook, mom, and storyteller behind StephanieCooksForACrowd.com. She cooks for a family of seven in Florida — five kids, two cats, and one husband who appreciates a good meal. Four of her children came home through adoption, and family stories are woven into everything she makes and shares. Find her crowd-friendly recipes, weekly meal plans, and real family life on TikTok, Instagram, YouTube, and Pinterest @stephaniecooksforacrowd.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *