The Hill I Will Die On: Team Dunkin’ Donuts Over Starbucks, All Day, Every Day

Dunkin vs Starbucks is a fight I did not even know I had an opinion on until recently, because I just realized I like both. But when it comes to planting my flag on a hill, I am team Dunkin’ Donuts over Starbucks. All day. Every day. ☕
This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. If you purchase through my links, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Thank you for supporting StephanieCooksForACrowd.com!
I just realized I like both, but when it comes to planting my flag on a hill, I am team Dunkin’ Donuts over Starbucks. All day. Every day. What team are you on?
Let me explain myself. I am not here to tell you Starbucks is bad. I have walked out of a Starbucks happy plenty of times. But Starbucks feels like a treat, and Dunkin’ feels like a habit, and a habit is what you pick when somebody says you only get one. My order is a medium iced coffee with southern butter pecan cream, a toasted bagel with a light amount of cream cheese, and a sour cream donut. 😊🥯🍩🧋 And yes, I know I wrote a whole Tuesday tip about making your breakfast bagel at home. I stand by every word of it. This is a hill, not a budget. It tastes like coffee, it does not try too hard, and it has never once made my eyes water.
The realization came on my way up to the hospital to be with Jon. Jason and I take turns staying with him so he is never by himself, and I was driving up to swap out with Jason. Somewhere on that drive I started thinking about what I would get at each place, and hands down, I wanted Dunkin’ more. And I think I would choose it over and over again.
Here is the case against me, and I am going to state it fairly. Starbucks is on every corner. It has a drink for every mood, a seasonal cup for every holiday, and a coffee that is bold on purpose. A lot of people love that bold flavor, and Starbucks built a whole empire on it. All true. But it turns out a whole lot of people do not love it, and the company that told me so was Starbucks.
Dunkin vs Starbucks — The Backup I Found
Y’all know I do not plant a flag without going to find some backup, and this one came back better than I hoped. In February 2011, Rasmussen Reports called 1,000 American adults and asked them about coffee. Among the coffee drinkers, 23% said they were most likely to buy their coffee at Starbucks, and only 14% said Dunkin’ Donuts. So more people were buying Starbucks. But when they asked how people felt about each one, 57% of coffee drinkers had a favorable opinion of Dunkin’, and only 49% said the same about Starbucks. Rasmussen’s headline says it better than I can: coffee drinkers buy Starbucks more, but they like Dunkin’ better.
That is my whole Dunkin vs Starbucks hill in one survey. I like both. I just like one of them better.
And then Starbucks went and confessed. In January 2012, Starbucks rolled out its Blonde Roast, the first milder brewed coffee in the company’s 40-year history. Why? Its own research found that about 40% of American coffee drinkers, around 54 million people, prefer a lighter roast. One of their own executives said it was for the people who find Starbucks’ signature roast too intense. Nation’s Restaurant News covered the launch, and the reporting at the time pointed out that Dunkin’ was already serving a lighter roast. So 54 million of us were right all along, and Dunkin’ had been pouring our cup the whole time.
Now, I promised you fair. The closest thing to an official Dunkin vs Starbucks taste test came from Consumer Reports back in 2007, when trained tasters drank black coffee from four chains. They called Starbucks strong, but burnt and bitter. They were not exactly kind to Dunkin’ either. They called it inoffensive and said it had no oomph. And the winner of that whole taste test was McDonald’s. I am choosing to hear “inoffensive” as “easy to drink every single morning,” and I am not taking questions.
Dunkin vs Starbucks vs Jason’s Kitchen Counter
Jason loves a great cup of coffee, and he likes it flavored. What he does not love is paying a coffee shop to make it for him. He makes his at home with a K-cup from The Original Donut Shop and a few pumps of sugar free Torani vanilla syrup . Yes, his coffee is literally called Donut Shop. I am counting that as a vote for my side.
So we did the Dunkin vs Starbucks math, then added Jason’s kitchen, on the same coffee three ways: regular brewed coffee with three pumps of vanilla. When we checked the stores closest to our house in November 2026, a grande Pike Place at Starbucks was $2.95, and three pumps of sugar free vanilla added another $0.80, for $3.75 before tax. A medium Original Blend at Dunkin’ with three vanilla shots came to $2.89 before tax. And Jason’s cup at home, with one K-cup out of a 72-count box and three pumps of Torani, works out to about $0.95. To be fair, a grande is 16 ounces and a Dunkin’ medium is 14, and Jason’s mug is a little smaller than both. Prices change from store to store, so check yours.
One cup a day for a year comes to about $1,369 at Starbucks, $1,055 at Dunkin’, and $347 at Jason’s kitchen counter. So Dunkin’ saves me around $300 a year over Starbucks, and Jason saves around $1,000. He would like that on the record. It is on the record.
Dunkin’ Dropped the Donuts. I Did Not.
Here is the twist. You may have noticed I keep saying Dunkin’ Donuts. The company does not. Dunkin’ announced in 2018 that it was dropping the word “Donuts” from its name, and it made the change official in January 2019. I have not complied, and here is why. The name started in Quincy, Massachusetts, where Bill Rosenberg opened a little coffee and donut shop called Open Kettle in 1948. By 1950 it was Dunkin’ Donuts, named for the way his customers dunked their donuts in their coffee, and it advertised the “world’s finest coffee” for ten cents a cup. Dunkin’s own history page has the whole story, right down to the donuts they made with a handle so you could dunk them without a mess.
So the name was always about having both, the coffee and the donut, together. That is exactly where I started. I like both. I just know which one I am dunking. And that same history page says that in 1997 Dunkin’ added its first flavored coffees, French Vanilla and Hazelnut, which y’all know is another hill I will die on.
If you want something to dunk at home, my Bisquick Cinnamon Coffee Cake costs less to make for the whole pan than one slice at a coffee shop.
Hill I Will Die On — Dunkin vs Starbucks FAQ
Dunkin vs Starbucks: which one is cheaper?
At our stores in November 2026, Dunkin’ was. A medium Original Blend with three vanilla shots was $2.89, and a grande Pike Place with three pumps of sugar free vanilla was $3.75, both before tax. Making it at home with a K-cup and Torani came out to about $0.95, which is why Jason does not have a team.
Isn’t Starbucks coffee just stronger?
It tastes bolder, because Starbucks built its name on a dark roast. But bold is not the same as better, and Starbucks’ own research found that about 40% of American coffee drinkers prefer a lighter roast. That is why they launched Blonde Roast in 2012.
Didn’t Consumer Reports say Dunkin’ had no oomph?
They did, back in 2007, and they called Starbucks burnt and bitter in the same test. Neither one won. McDonald’s did. I will take inoffensive over making my eyes water any day of the week.
Why do you still call it Dunkin’ Donuts?
Because that is its name, and it was its name for almost 70 years before they shortened it in 2019. The whole name comes from dunking your donut in your coffee. You cannot take the donut out of that and expect me to go along with it.
So do you ever go to Starbucks?
Of course I do. I like both, remember? This is a hill about which one I would pick if I could only have one, and that answer is Dunkin’, every time.
☕ Whatever Team You’re On, Pour It in One of My Mugs
Dunkin’, Starbucks or a K-cup at home, it all tastes better in a good mug. These are big 15-ounce mugs, because that is how I like them, and the words on them are mine, written in my own hand.
Come to the Table, Y’all
My sign-off on one side, our utensil crock on the other.
See the Come to the Table mug →
Let’s Bring Back Sunday Dinner, Y’all
In red gingham or red stripe, with a red handle and a red inside.
So that is where I stand on Dunkin vs Starbucks, and it is the hill I will die on: I like both, but I am team Dunkin’ Donuts over Starbucks, all day, every day, and now I have a survey, a confession and a donut with a handle to back me up. Now tell me, what team are you on? Dunkin’, Starbucks, or Jason’s kitchen counter? Put it in the comments, and I will read every single one. And if you are team Starbucks, I still love you. I will even meet you there. I just know what I am ordering on the way home. 😉
More Hills Worth Dying On — Strong Food Opinions from Stephanie
- The Hill I Will Die On: Pumpkin Spice Is the Best Coffee Flavor — the time I found out the pumpkin spice latte went twelve years without any actual pumpkin in it.
- The Hill I Will Die On: Hazelnut Is the Best Flavor — when my coffee tastes extra good, this is why, and Dunkin’ has been pouring it since 1997.
- The Hill I Will Die On: Coffee Really Does Taste Better in the Right Mug — because once you have picked your coffee, the mug still matters, and science backs me up.
- Every hill, sorted by the kind of argument — all my strong food opinions in one place, or browse them newest first.
📬 Come to the table on Saturday
Every Saturday morning I send a printable meal plan and full grocery list — the whole week, formatted for the fridge and the grocery run — plus new recipes and whatever’s happening at the Longstreth house. Drop your email below and I’ll save you a seat.
The Hill I Will Die On — About Stephanie Longstreth
Stephanie Longstreth is the home cook, mom, and storyteller behind StephanieCooksForACrowd.com. She cooks for a family of seven in Florida — five kids, two cats, and one husband who appreciates a good meal. Four of her children came home through adoption, and family stories are woven into everything she makes and shares. Find her crowd-friendly recipes, weekly meal plans, and real family life on TikTok, Instagram, YouTube, and Pinterest @stephaniecooksforacrowd.
