Tuesday Tip: Serrated Knife vs Chef’s Knife — Why Onions Make You Cry
Serrated knife vs chef’s knife — have you ever noticed yourself reaching for a different knife depending on which veggie you’re cutting? I grab a serrated knife with the little teeth every single time I slice tomatoes, but I pick up my straight-edge chef’s knife when I’m chopping onions. I never really thought about why. Turns out there’s actually a reason behind it, and it’s a good one.
This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. If you purchase through my links, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Thank you for supporting StephanieCooksForACrowd.com!
Watch the full video above — or keep reading below.
Why a Serrated Knife Wins on Tomatoes
A tomato has that soft, slick, glossy skin, and a smooth blade just wants to slide right off it. A serrated knife saws through instead. The little teeth puncture the skin and actually grab onto it, so the knife slides through without slipping or squishing. A chef’s knife, unless it is razor sharp, tends to press down on a tomato and crush it before it ever breaks the skin. That’s how you end up with tomato juice all over your cutting board and a slice that looks like it lost a fight.
So if you’ve been reaching for the knife with the teeth for your tomatoes, you’ve been doing it right all along.
Serrated Knife vs Chef’s Knife on Onions — and Why Onions Make You Cry
An onion is the opposite. It’s built in rigid, firm layers, and a straight-edge chef’s knife cuts cleanly right through them. A serrated knife does the exact thing you don’t want — it rips and tears the onion cells instead of slicing them. Every cell you tear open lets out more of the gas that makes you cry. It’s called syn-propanethial-S-oxide, and I’m going to be honest with you, y’all: I had to read that one off my sticky note. It’s too long for me to remember!
Clean cuts tear fewer cells, and fewer torn cells mean less of that gas floating up to your eyes. It’s not just a kitchen old wives’ tale, either — physicists actually tested this, and thin, sharp blades sent up far less of the onion spray than dull ones. So a straight-edge knife gives you two things at once: fewer tears and nicer cuts. If yours is getting dull, a good chef's knife is the upgrade that makes the biggest difference — everything gets easier with a sharp one.

Which Knife to Reach For
Here’s the whole tip in one line: teeth for slick skins, straight edge for firm layers. Tomatoes get the serrated knife. Onions and peppers get the chef’s knife. And if you find yourself reaching for a certain knife for a certain veggie, you are doing a good thing — your hands figured it out before your head did.
Whatever knife you use, give it a good board to land on. A soft bamboo board is easier on your blades than glass or stone. I wrote about the bamboo cutting boards I use every day, and how I oil bamboo boards so they last.
Happy chopping, y’all. Come to the table — it’s time to eat!
Serrated Knife vs Chef’s Knife FAQ — Your Knife Questions
Serrated knife vs chef’s knife — which one should I buy first?
The chef’s knife. It handles onions, peppers, carrots, garlic, chicken, and just about everything else you chop for dinner. A serrated knife is the second one I’d add, mostly for tomatoes and bread.
Can I cut tomatoes with a chef’s knife?
You can if it’s very sharp. A truly sharp chef’s knife will slice a tomato fine, but most of our home knives aren’t that sharp, and that’s when the tomato squishes. A serrated knife stays grippy on that skin even when it’s not freshly sharpened.
Why does a dull knife make onions worse?
A dull blade crushes and tears more of the onion’s cells as it goes through, and every torn cell lets out more of the gas that makes your eyes water. A sharp straight edge slices the layers cleanly, so fewer cells break and you cry less.
What’s the gas that makes you cry when you cut onions?
It’s called syn-propanethial-S-oxide. When you cut into an onion and break its cells, it forms and floats up to your eyes, and your eyes make tears to wash it away. Clean cuts make less of it.
What else is a serrated knife good for?
Bread, for sure — it saws through a crusty loaf without smashing the soft middle. It’s also great for anything with a slick or waxy skin, like peaches and plums.
📅 New here?
Every Tuesday Tip I have shared lives on my Tuesday Tips page — sorted by what you need, from feeding a crowd to stretching the grocery budget.
More Tuesday Tips You’ll Love
- Tuesday Tip: Cutting Boards — How to Oil Bamboo Boards So They Last — take care of the board your knives land on.
- Tuesday tip: cooking meat — 3 Tips to Make It Turn Out Amazing Every Time — more kitchen know-how that makes dinner easier.
- Tuesday Tip: Why Your Food Tastes Flat — 3 Fixes That Actually Work — once it’s chopped, here’s how to make it taste great.
- Every Tuesday tip, newest first — all my kitchen and money-saving tips in one place.
📬 Come to the table on Saturday
Every Saturday morning I send a printable meal plan and full grocery list — the whole week, formatted for the fridge and the grocery run — plus new recipes and whatever’s happening at the Longstreth house. Drop your email below and I’ll save you a seat.
Serrated Knife vs Chef’s Knife — About Stephanie’s Tips
Stephanie Longstreth is the home cook, mom, and storyteller behind StephanieCooksForACrowd.com. She cooks for a family of seven in Florida — five kids, two cats, and one husband who appreciates a good meal. Four of her children came home through adoption, and family stories are woven into everything she makes and shares. Find her crowd-friendly recipes, weekly meal plans, and real family life on TikTok, Instagram, YouTube, and Pinterest @stephaniecooksforacrowd.
